The Post-Standard News
Archives

Click here to go back to Bullett NewsStand.

Post-Standard, The (Syracuse, NY)

February 16, 2003
Section: News
Edition: Final
Page: A1

BIGGEST WINDMILL IN U.S. ON DECK FOR OSWEGO

   Chris Iven Staff writer

Electricity-generating plants in Oswego County split atoms, harness the energy of rivers and burn natural gas and oil.

By the end of this year, according to a developer, a new facility in Oswego should produce electricity with a new energy source: wind. UPC Wind Management of Massachusetts plans to be the first in the nation to place a wind turbine offshore. And it plans to use what would be the largest, most powerful wind turbine in the nation, scraping the air nearly 500 feet off the ground. Only a prototype operating in Barrax, Spain, compares in size and power.

That windmill would join a smaller 350-foot windmill in Lake Ontario on the breakwater near Oswego this year, according to Brian Braginton-Smith, vice president of project development for UPC.

Over the next few years, the company would like to place about 80 of the larger windmills farther offshore and as many as 20 of the smaller versions on land near the lake.

"It will establish Oswego, New York, as a wind energy center," Braginton-Smith said.

And it will begin to establish the area as a center for other renewable energy sources as well, according to Carolyn Rush, executive director of the Center for Business and Community Programs at the State University College at Oswego.

The college, less than a half-mile from the breakwater, had been studying the advantages of placing its own windmills on campus for several months when it learned of UPC's proposals, Rush said.

"When we heard about Brian's project, we expanded our thinking," said Rush, who also chairs the county's Industrial Development Agency. A college task force has developed a proposal to create the Great Lakes Renewable Energy Center, she said. The center would study wind energy as well as solar energy, fuel cells and hydrogen fuel.

"The potential for this project is very, very exciting," Rush said.

General Electric, producer of the new large turbine, has been looking for a site to test it offshore in the United States, Braginton-Smith said. Two other partners, the city of Oswego and the county Industrial Development Agency, have been looking for ways to boost economic development in the area.

"It just turns out to be a synchronicity that all these entities were thinking about how to become engaged in this arena," Braginton-Smith said. "All of the players believe this is the right time, the right place and that this is a very exciting opportunity."

Oswego Mayor John Gosek said he hopes the development can attract jobs from companies that want to join in the renewable energy research.

"We're hoping that Oswego can be a national center, not just for windmills, but for hydrogen cell development, solar and other energy sources," Gosek said.

That may be possible, said L. Michael Treadwell, executive director of Operation Oswego County, the county's designated economic development agency.

"It would be a pilot project which would necessitate a lot of r and d (research and development) activities," he said. "There's a lot of potential and the potential keeps growing."

Braginton-Smith has already begun the site approval process. Last week, he met with members of the Army Corps of Engineers, which manages the breakwater.

"They were all very excited and were very supportive of the concept," Braginton-Smith said. "There was a general consensus that this shouldn't have any serious obstacles in front of it."

Assuming the approval process continues smoothly, the only major hurdle is to gather the $6 million to $7 million needed to erect the first two turbines. Braginton-Smith said he is not worried.

"If you know what you're doing, you can find money, but you can't find local support if it isn't there," he said. "The main issue, in truth, is in establishing the collaborative spirit that exists."

The strong winds that gather speed crossing Lake Ontario can bring as much as 250 inches of snow to Oswego annually. Those winds, combined with the county's existing electricity transmission infrastructure, make it an ideal location for wind energy production, Braginton-Smith said.

"The city of Oswego, by virtue of its location, has the potential to become a major center for Great Lake-based offshore renewable energy," he said. "Wind energy is just one of them."

In his recent state of the state address, Gov. George Pataki announced a policy of supporting renewable energy projects. By 2013, he wants 25 percent of all electricity produced in the state to come from renewable sources.

That would require at least 2,000 megawatts of new capacity from wind, solar or other renewable sources, according to Tom Collins, spokesman for the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority.

The greatest cost associated with making electricity with windmills is in the structures, since the energy source, wind, is free. Still, wind projects likely would not be profitable without government incentives, Collins said.

State Sen. Jim Wright, chairman of the senate's energy committee, said the Oswego windmill project should have little difficulty winning economic assistance from the state.

"This is exactly what the governor envisions," Wright said.

In August, the Energy and Research Development Authority awarded $17 million in economic incentives to five wind projects in the state which, collectively, would create 315 megawatts of generating capacity.

While those windmills will produce no air pollution, producing the same amount of electricity using fossil fuels would release 650 tons of nitrogen oxides, 1,300 tons of sulfur dioxide, and 400,000 tons of carbon dioxide.

Windmills placed offshore near Oswego County could have a collective capacity of 300 megawatts, Braginton-Smith said. For the lake as a whole, the number is in the thousands, he said. The cost of erecting those offshore windmills would be between $390 million and $420 million, he said.

Even anglers have reason to be happy about the development, Braginton-Smith said. The rocky footing the windmills require are an ideal breeding ground for indigenous fish, he said.

Power House

Oswego County already produces more electricity than any other county in the state. Although the county encompasses about 2 percent of the state's land and 0.6 percent of its population, its electricity producing capacity is 5,500 megawatts - nearly 16 percent of the state total. The largest share of that capacity comes from the three nuclear power plants on the Lake Ontario shoreline in Scriba. Collectively, the plants have a generating capacity of more than 2,500 megawatts.

Windfall

Central New York and its economy would benefit from establishing a renewable energy research center in Oswego, according to L. Michael Treadwell, executive director of Operation Oswego County. Here are some benefits on his list:

Construction jobs: Erecting the turbines takes skilled labor.

New jobs: The number of workers needed to maintain wind turbines is small, but the positions would be high-paying. The project could also create "spin-off" jobs in research and technical support.

More new jobs: If companies are to be required to purchase electricity from renewable sources in the future, some companies may decide to locate near those sources.

Retained jobs: The on-shore windmills envisioned as part of the project can be linked with local industries. That could stabilize and lower the energy costs for the industries, making them more competitive.

Good public relations: "It's going to help market the community as being a little innovative," Treadwell said.

Tourism: "People do travel to visit and look at these wind turbine projects," he said.

How tall will it be?

Proposed wind turbine 500 feet

Washington Monument 555 feet

Statue of Liberty 305 feet
Illustration: GRAPHIC: Harnessing the wind
A developer wants to put more than 80 wind turbines offshore in Lake
Ontario, near Oswego. The biggest turbine has a generating capacity of
3.6 megawatts. If completed, the project would produce enough
electricity to power as many as 300,000 homes.
POWER STATION 328 FEET HIGH
On top of the tubular steel tower, the computer-controlled turbine is
housed in a 50-foot enclosure, directly behind the three-bladed hub.
The computer monitors the speed and direction of the wind to keep the
turbine facing directly into the wind and always spinning at optimum
speed.
PITCH CONTROL
Winds are notoriously gusty on Lake Ontario. To compensate for any
change in wind speed, the blades rotate within the rotor hub. This
changes the pitch of the blade relative to the increase or decrease of
wind speed. The blade pitch allows the turbine to keep spinning at the
desired speed of between 8.5 and 15.3 rpm.
PHOTO
iMAGES GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY.
THE GE 3.6 MW Wind Turbine operating in Barrax, Spain.
A YAW CONTROL.

As the wind shifts in direction, the turbine turns to face into the
wind. The turbine cannot operate effectively unless it always faces
the wind. A computer monitors wind direction and sends the information
to the yaw drive. The entire turbine rotates around the tower.
lLike Madison County One of the two windmills planned for the Oswego
breakwater would be about350 feet tall and similar to those in the
town of Fenner, Madison County, according to UPC Wind Management. The
other would be as tall as 500 feet and, at 3.6 megawatts, the most
powerful U.S. windmill.

The Post-Standard.

Copyright, 2003, The Herald Company
Purchased for use on the Borodino Bullett.